Skip to main content

2014/15 AHSMC Part 1 Problem 13

Problem 13 of 16

Three candles which can burn for 3030, 4040 and 5050 minutes respectively are lit at different times. All three candles are burning simultaneously for 1010 minutes, and there is a total of 2020 minutes in which exactly one of them is burning. The number of minutes in which exactly two of them are burning is

Answer choices

Show solution

Solution

Count the number of minutes in which each candle is burning and add them together. The ten minutes of simultaneous burning contributes 3030 minutes to this, and there are 2020 minutes of individual burning. The total must be 30+40+50=12030+40+50=120 minutes, so the time when exactly two candles are burning must contribute the remaining 120−30−20=70120-30-20=70 minutes. Thus the answer must be 70/2=3570/2=35.

Alternative Solution: Let the first two candles burn simultaneously for aa minutes, the first and the third for bb minutes and the last two for cc minutes. Then the first candle burns alone for 20−a−b20 - a - b minutes, the second for 30−a−c30 - a - c minutes and the third for 40−b−c40 - b - c minutes. Hence 90−2(a+b+c)=2090 - 2(a+b+c) = 20 so that a+b+c=35a + b + c = 35. This may be realized if a=0a = 0, b=20b = 20 and c=15c = 15. The three candles are lit at minutes 3030, 00 and 1515 respectively. The answer is (A).